Skip to main content

Q&A: Help me find a quality normal prime lens?

Already another question and answer post! Keep them coming. 🙂 Sharing information is a great way for everyone to learn. Edit: I have to say, I like the way he thinks. Why waste money on an inferior lens if you will eventually replace it? Opting to start with that 50-135mm f2.8 lens was a good idea. I’d say, If you have the cash, it is often a good idea to truly consider the high quality equipment for your given system of choice. On the other hand, the most expensive lens isn’t always the best. In my response, I go over some issues I see with the 31mm lens, but it is still one of the best lenses out there.

The initial contact:

I bumped into you on Youtube, have been following your channel for a while now. Great stuff!

I’m in dire need for some advice, and I have a hunch I came to the right place. I recently got into photography and bought a k-5 and a DA 50-135mm. That’s my only lens (I spent my last buck on it:P, and I’m loving it) so now I am looking for something wider. I really badly need a normal prime (something around 35mm).

Since I have little experience both with lenses and photography in general I tend to follow a simple rule: the more expensive the better. So I keep returning to the FA 31mm 1.8. I know it sound snobbish for a hobbyist to go for such a classy lens, but I wouldn’t mind the expense if deep down I knew it is worth it and simply if I enjoyed it to the last of the 1000$. Truth be told I am looking for a normal prime that would be my main lens that I can grow to love and wouldn’t get it off my camera – in which case it really can’t be too expensive. On the other hand, if I’m paying for the metal casing and sexy look it’s a huge waste. Are there other lenses that I can get away with cheaper? I don’t mind it being manual focus, I just want it to be above average in IQ and fast (at least f2, but probably even faster). What about the FA 35mm f2 AL? Or if you know of any respected old lenses that I can buy used. Are there current Carl Zeiss lenses for K mount?
What about the new crop sensor ones?

I plan to do some industrial photography so I need it to be decently sharp.

It is clear that the price for each lens is justified to a certain extent. The problem is I don’t EXACTLY know what I would be getting/loosing for the extra $. I want a lens that I won’t be needing to upgrade in a year or two, because in that case 150$ would be more expensive that a 1000$. I guess, simply put, I need a “lovable lens”.

Thanks.

P.s. If the price is right, I don’t mind not having AF.

My response:

I probably can give you more to think about at least.

The Zeiss lens are very expensive. There is a Zeiss 28mm f2 lens, but it’s a good $250 more expensive than the 31mm Pentax lens. I have not used Zeiss lenses, so I can’t comment on them. They are well regarded though.
The Sigma 30mm f1.4 probably would not be a good option because reviews say the corners are not very sharp throughout most of the aperture range.

I like my 31mm lens, but it isn’t perfect. For some reason, my 31mm lens is currently front focusing on my K-5 (I recently did a small photoshoot and noticed it, switched to live-view for focusing and it was perfect). So lately I have been using it in live-view mode as I have not spent the time to try and adjust the focus correction function in the camera. The 31mm is my go-to lens for videos. It’s wide enough for most situations, but not too wide, and of course the resulting quality is good. Another few negative things are the lens hood is integrated into the lens itself (designed for full-frame) and it doesn’t have quick-shift functionality (the 31mm was made before they released that feature).

I wrote an article comparing the kit lens at around 31mm to the FA 31mm:
http://photographybanzai.com/2011/09/19/comparison-pentax-fa-31mm-f1-8-limited-vs-pentax-da-18-55mm-f3-5-5-6-31mm/

I also have a review I wrote up on the 31mm as well:
http://photographybanzai.com/2011/09/29/lens-review-pentax-fa-31mm-f1-8-limited/

It certainly is a good lens, but like anything it isn’t perfect and I do see some things I’d like Pentax to change with a revision.

There is the Pentax FA35mm f2 lens. There are some used ones right now on keh.com for around $430. The DA 35mm f2.4 is said to be a child of this design. I think either one is a good option, but I personally don’t know if they are as sharp and contrasty as the 31mm lens because I’ve never used them.

Then we have the FA* 24mm f2 lens. Some people think it is great, others not so much. You could probably find a used one around $250 less than the 31mm lens. I really want this lens, but lacking in the fund department at the moment.

This recent thread on Pentax Forums about 24mm lenses might be helpful:
http://www.pentaxforums.com/forums/pentax-slr-lens-discussion/173864-24mm-lens.html

Popular posts from this blog

Viltrox AF FE 28mm f/4.5 VCM ASPH ED Lens Overview

Viltrox asked me if I wanted to take a look at this unique compact autofocus full-frame prime lens with a focal length of 28mm and a fixed f/4.5 aperture for Sony E-mount cameras. Viltrox agreed to my standard collaboration terms before sending me the lens.    In the video I talk about features, how it works in practice, and show photos I had taken on a photo walk with the Sony a7S as well as the APS-C a6000. Viltrox is starting this off as an Indiegogo campaign. They told me that it will eventually be sold through normal retailers: https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/viltrox-af-28mm-f4-5-fe-chips-size-ultra-thin-lens They said it will be $99 USD or 109 Euros with discounts during the crowdfunding period. Check out Indiegogo for details. I am not an affiliate of that website. You can check on the status of availability through my usual affiliates: B&H Photo Video Amazon As an affiliate of these shops, I earn from qualifying purchases!    The front of the lens. K...

First look at the Sigma 18-50mm F/2.8 for Sony E-mount bought from KEH

I've use a Sony Alpha A6000 and the PZ 16–50mm F/3.5–5.6 OSS kit lens with my computer as a webcam for a long time now. It's a lower cost option that has been very consistent outputting 1080p at 30 FPS to a USB based HDMI capture device. The kit lens is generally fine, but it has a few quirks. The biggest issue is that throughout the zoom range the maximum aperture value is not fixed. This introduces technical challenges when I want to show detailed views of product or similar use cases. There are also other considerations I'll talk about later in this article. So I decided to buy the Sigma 18-50mm F2.8 DC DN | C lens in E-mount as a replacement.  Links in this article are a mix of paid and through my affiliates. I earn from each in different ways. One is a flat fee and the others I earn from qualifying purchases. Considering them for your purchasing needs helps make the creation of this information viable!   I made a video unboxing the lens and trying it out with Open ...

Camera Gear Reviews and Marketing Issues Exposed

A great overview by Gerald Undone on his experiences in the field of camera gear related videos! It is an important topic. The more open the better, I’d say. After over 13 years making photography and videography gear videos, I’ve not had a huge amount of success comparatively, but I’ve also never been especially brand safe to begin with for these companies to consider me. 🤣 I think his mentions toward the end of the video are especially important. The unwritten pressure, or worse with companies like Insta360 , shouldn’t be acceptable and should be publicly called out more often. That’s probably the only way things will actually change for the better. I created a video detailing my opinion on the topic further: More of my comments on the video… His YouTube channel. 4:30 I understand that’s what Gerald does, but are there situations where companies are paying for flights and hotel costs of other reviewers with the expectation of a video/article being produced? (EDIT: I’ve seen confirm...